CBD edibles are in the news this morning after a massive recall on Extract Labs CBD gummies. What does this mean for you, the consumer? Let’s take a closer look at the Extract Labs recall and see how this company compares to one of the oldest and most trusted brands in CBD: CBDfx.
Who Is Extract Labs?
Based in Lafayette, Colorado, Extract Labs has been in the CBD business since 2016. Founded by a CO2 extraction expert, Craig Henderson, the company prides itself on safe manufacturing practices and broad selection of CBD products.
Extract Labs CBD Gummies Recall
On September 26, 2025, it was reported that Extract Labs had a Class II recall of four of their CBD gummy products: Sugar-Free Mixed Berry Gummies, Elderberry 20mg Gummies, and Blue Razz 20mg Gummies, and Mai Tai 20mg Gummies. According to the FDA, a Class II recall is “a situation in which use of or exposure to a violative product may cause temporary or medically reversible adverse health consequences or where the probability of serious adverse health consequences is remote.”
According to the FDA report, the Extract Labs gummies in question were recalled due to a “potential peanut protein cross-contact.” According to this same report, the recalled gummies were distributed throughout the United States as well as Australia, Germany, United Kingdom, Malaysia, and New Zealand.
Who Is CBDfx?
CBDfx was founded in 2014 by wellness experts Jameson Rodgers and Ali Esmaili. For over a decade now, CBDfx has been a leader in the CBD industry due in no small part to their commitment to safety and quality. CBDfx CBD and THC gummies are perennially among the most highly rated hemp gummies in the world. In fact, just this year, CBDfx won four awards for Best CBD Gummies of 2025 from Healthline. Here are those awards:
- Best for Daytime Pain Relief (“We Tested the 4 Best CBD Gummies for Pain”)
- Best for Low Energy Caused by Poor Sleep (“CBD for Energy and Focus: Can It Help?”)
- Best Extra-Strength Gummies (“5 Best Broad-Spectrum CBD Products”)
- Strongest Broad Spectrum CBD Gummies (“The 4 Strongest CBD Gummies for March 2025”)
How Do CBDfx and Extract Labs CBD Gummies Compare?
Customers can get uneasy after a product recall. Certainly, even the best of consumable manufacturers can experience the unfortunate mishap of cross-contamination. But events like this do provide customers the opportunity to compare the products they plan on putting into their bodies with alternatives from other brands. With that in mind, let’s take a look at how Extract Labs gummies compare with CBDfx gummies.
Organic Hemp
Using organic hemp is vital to making a safe CBD product. Hemp is a bioaccumulator, meaning that it absorbs everything from the soil that surrounds the plant. If your hemp isn’t organic, you could be consuming pesticides, heavy metals, and other toxic compounds. Of the 18 gummies listed on Extract Labs’ website, only six are made with organic hemp. In contrast, all gummies produced by CBDfx are made with organic hemp. Verdict: CBDfx Wins!
Manufacturing Practices
Both Extract Labs and CBDfx use clean carbon dioxide to extract the CBD oil from the hemp plant, avoiding any unwanted solvent residues that you might find in cheaper CBD products. And both companies adhere to Current Good Manufacturing Practices (cGMP) to ensure that they are consistently safe, effective, and of the highest quality. Verdict: Draw
Third-Party Lab Testing
Both companies use independent, third-party laboratories to test their products for purity and potency. And both companies post those reports (called a Certificate of Analysis) on their websites for customer transparency. Verdict: Draw
CBD Gummy Selection
Extract Labs offers 18 different gummies, including CBD isolate, broad spectrum CBD, full spectrum CBD, and THC gummies. Some of these 18 are simply flavor variations of other gummies. Still, it is a robust collection with formulas for sleep, mood, kava, and daily wellness support.
CBDfx offers six different CBD gummies and four different THC gummies. Each of these gummies is formulated for different effects and benefits. The CBD gummies include variations for sleep, multivitamins, superfoods like turmeric and spirulina, apple cider vinegar for diet and detox, as well as daily wellness support. CBDfx THC gummies come in formulas for microdosing, sleep, and deeper stress relief and relaxation.
Both offer customers a good variety that largely comes down to personal preference. Verdict: Draw
Medical Advisory Board
CBDfx consults with a medical advisory board of licensed doctors and pharmacists to test and consult on their products. All of CBDfx’s CBD gummies come with a medical review on each product’s web page. Extract Labs lists no such board on their website. Verdict: CBDfx Wins!
Which Is Better: CBDfx or Extract Labs Edibles?
While both CBDfx and Extract Labs have been in the CBD industry for a long time and offer many similar benefits in their CBD gummy collections, CBDfx has the advantage in safe, organic hemp, as well as the peace of mind from using a medical advisory board on their gummies. Verdict: CBDfx Wins!
